Middle school science classes are designed to offer students a comprehensive introduction to various scientific disciplines, including physical science, life science, earth and space sciences, and technology. This article compares the two core standards shaping the middle school science curriculum in the Golden State — the Integrated Model Standards and the Discipline Specific Model Standards. Given the widespread use of the Discipline Specific Model in private schools, we also examine the specific science learning areas from grade 6 to grade 8 at The Nueva School. Read on as we unpack these standards and their implications for nurturing scientific curiosity and understanding among students.

Integrated Model Standards VS. Discipline Specific Model Standards

In the realm of middle school science, the CA NGSS (California Next Generation Science Standards) delineates two intriguing progressions: the highly-preferred Integrated Model, seamlessly intertwining science disciplines in a developmentally appropriate sequence, and the equally compelling Discipline Specific Model, offering a deep dive into distinct scientific disciplines at each grade level.

These models primarily diverge in their sequencing, yet share a common goal — ensuring every student masters each middle-grade performance expectation by the end of the academic year. In this context, “sequence” refers to the specific grade (sixth, seventh, or eighth) where a particular Performance Expectation (PE) is mastered. Join us as we explore these dynamic pathways, providing valuable insights into the intricacies of the CA NGSS and how they shape the science education landscape in middle school.

Grade 6

	Integrated Model	Discipline Specific Model
From Molecules to Organisms: Structures and Processes	✅
Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits	✅
Earth’s Systems	✅	✅
Earth and Human Activity	✅	✅
Energy	✅
Engineering Design	✅	✅
Earth’s Place in the Universe		✅

Integrated Model:

• Focuses on interconnected scientific concepts across disciplines.
• Emphasizes systems thinking, such as understanding the body as a system.
• Encourages practical applications, like designing methods for monitoring and minimizing human impact on the environment.
• Integrates engineering design principles throughout.

Discipline Specific Model:

• Emphasizes specialized knowledge in distinct scientific domains.
• Focuses on specific phenomena, like celestial motions and geoscience processes.
• Provides in-depth exploration of Earth’s systems and human impact within separate disciplines.
• Applies engineering design principles within a specialized context.

Grade 7

	Integrated Model	Discipline Specific Model
From Molecules to Organisms: Structures and Processes	✅	✅
Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits		✅
Ecosystems: Interactions, Energy, and Dynamics	✅	✅
Earth’s Systems	✅
Earth and Human Activity	✅
Matter and Its Interactions	✅
Engineering Design	✅	✅
Biological Evolution: Unity and Diversity		✅

Integrated Model:

• Integrates scientific concepts across different disciplines.
• Emphasizes systems thinking, particularly in understanding ecosystems and Earth’s systems.
• Encourages practical applications, like designing solutions for maintaining biodiversity.
• Promotes modeling and analysis in various scientific contexts.

Discipline Specific Model:

• Focuses on specialized knowledge within specific scientific domains.
• Emphasizes detailed exploration of biological concepts such as heredity and evolution.
• Provides in-depth understanding of Earth’s systems and ecosystems within distinct disciplines.
• Applies engineering design principles within specialized contexts.

Grade 8

	Integrated Model	Discipline Specific Model
Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits	✅
Ecosystems: Interactions, Energy, and Dynamics	✅
Earth’s Place in the Universe	✅
Earth and Human Activity	✅
Matter and Its Interactions		✅
Engineering Design	✅	✅
Biological Evolution: Unity and Diversity	✅
Motion and Stability: Forces and Interactions	✅	✅
Energy	✅	✅
Waves and Their Applications in Technologies for Information Transfer	✅	✅

Integrated Model:

• Integrates complex scientific concepts across different disciplines.
• Emphasizes advanced topics like heredity, evolution, Earth’s place in the universe, and energy transformations.
• Encourages in-depth modeling, analysis, and practical applications.
• Promotes advanced engineering design principles.

Discipline Specific Model:

• Focuses on specialized knowledge within specific scientific domains.
• Emphasizes detailed exploration of matter, motion, and energy concepts.
• Provides in-depth understanding of forces and interactions.
• Applies engineering design principles within specialized contexts, addressing advanced scientific principles.

Private School Spotlight: The Nueva School’s Science Education with Discipline Specific Model

Discipline Specific Model is widely used in private schools. Next, let’s take a closer look at the specific science learning elements for each grade at The Nueva School, one of the most popular private schools in the bay area.

Grade 6

The science program described here is dynamic and multifaceted, focusing on hands-on learning, critical thinking, and real-world applications.

1. Interdisciplinary Approach: The program integrates various disciplines such as mathematics, humanities, arts, Design Thinking, and engineering with the science curriculum. This encourages students to see the interconnectedness of different fields of study.
2. Real-World Application: By incorporating labs that demand data interpretation skills for analyzing scientific problems, students are prepared for practical application outside the classroom.
3. Integrated Cross-Curricular Projects: These projects blend subjects together to provide a more holistic education experience and show how scientific principles can be applied across different domains.
4. Observation and Inquiry-Based Learning: Students are taught to observe physical phenomena closely and develop their own questions and theories based on evidence they collect.
5. Excitement About Science: The ultimate aim is to spark a passion for science in students by helping them discover concepts that they can then apply in new and innovative ways.

Grade 7

The science program described is multifaceted and designed to provide students with a comprehensive understanding of scientific principles and their applications.

1. Interdisciplinary Approach: The program integrates multiple disciplines, including mathematics, humanities, arts, Design Thinking, and engineering. This approach allows students to see the interconnectedness of different fields and understand how scientific knowledge can be applied broadly.
2. Practical Application: Labs are a key component where students practice data interpretation to tackle scientific problems. This hands-on experience is crucial for understanding real-world scenarios. And cross-curricular projects further enable students to apply science in various contexts, promoting innovative thinking.
3. Skill Development: Students enhance their ability to observe physical phenomena critically. They learn to formulate questions and theories based on empirical evidence. The program emphasizes the development of analytical skills through exploration, experimentation, observation, practice, and discussion.

Grade 8

The description of the science program you provided indicates a comprehensive and modern approach to science education that emphasizes real-world relevance and interdisciplinary learning.

1. Interdisciplinary Methods: The program is designed to transcend traditional subject boundaries, combining different fields such as mathematics, humanities, arts, and engineering with science. This reflects an understanding that scientific inquiry doesn’t exist in a vacuum but is connected to various aspects of human knowledge and society.
2. Real-World Application: By focusing on real-world problems like food systems, students are more likely to find the material relevant and engaging. This can also help them understand the practical importance of scientific research.
3. Skill Development: Students are encouraged to develop crucial skills such as data interpretation, which is essential for analyzing scientific problems effectively.
4. Integrated Projects: Cross-curricular projects allow students to apply concepts from multiple disciplines simultaneously, fostering a more holistic understanding of complex issues.
5. Observation and Inquiry-Based Learning: Students learn by observing physical phenomena directly which helps them form their own questions and theories based on evidence they gather themselves – this is fundamental for developing critical thinking skills.
6. Excitement About Science: The goal is not just knowledge acquisition but also instilling a passion for discovery in students so that they feel excited about learning science.

For additional insights into The Nueva School, please read this article:

Ready for High School Science Courses at Think Academy

To facilitate a smoother transition from middle school science to high school science courses, Think Academy has introduced Ready for High School Science Courses, which is a one-semester program designed for 7th and 8th graders in the spring of 2024.

It is ideal for students who have completed Algebra 1 at school or are currently learning A1 at Think Academy. The curriculum encompasses physics, chemistry, and biology, each with five comprehensive lessons, accompanied by an introductory research class. By mastering the core concepts in these subjects, students will be well-prepared for high school science Honor courses. This integrated approach not only ensures academic readiness but also assists students in discovering their strengths and interests in STEM subjects at an early stage.

Two goals of the Ready for High School Science Courses:

• Expanding the system to match high school-level difficulty and boosting a child’s self-motivation to learn.
• Ignite STEM subject interest and acquire fundamental research skills.

If you are interested in this course, feel free to contact us at +1 (844) 844-6587.

Hope the above content can help students and parents better understand the diverse systems and characteristics of middle school science curriculum design, as well as the phased learning focus. Interested in exploring more middle school resources, both inside and outside the classroom? Read the following articles:

• Math Education Progress: California Common Core Standards and Contrasts in Public and Private Schools
• 12 Popular and Worthwhile Competitions for Middle Schoolers
• Top Picks of Winter Camps: Middle Schoolers’ Adventure!
• Harker vs. Nueva: An In-depth Comparison Across 5 Key Aspects

Subscribe to our newsletter for educational insights and the latest trends.